Remember the European Corn Borer?
The European corn borer, once regarded as a major and consistent insect pest, is now only rarely observed in most commercial cornfields across the Corn Belt. William “Bill” Luckmann, longtime retired and well known entomologist, once mentioned that he had only observed two cornfields “totally destroyed” by insects — “once by chinch bugs and once by European corn borers.”
Gray, M.E. & W.H. Luckmann. 1994. Integrating the cropping system for corn insect pest management. Chapter 12, pages 507-541 in Introduction to Insect Pest Management. R.L. Metcalf & W.H. Luckmann [eds.], John Wiley & Sons, Inc., NY (ISBN 0-471-58957-8).
In 1939, European corn borers were first reported in Illinois and by 1942 the pest could be found in all counties within the state. The circular below attests to the economic importance of this insect and offers management advice for producers in 1943.
Since the introduction of Bt hybrids in 1996, the use of transgenic corn has risen sharply. According to the USDA Economic Research Service, Bt hybrids were planted on 76% of the US corn acres in 2013. In 2013, transgenic corn hybrids (includes Bt hybrids, stacked hybrids [Bt and herbicide tolerant], and herbicide tolerant only) were used on 90% of corn acres. The widespread use of highly effective Bt hybrids on lepidopterous insect pests such as the European corn borer has had a significant areawide population suppression effect on this once prominent species. In evening drives around the state of Illinois the past few years, the first or second flights of European corn borers have been barely noticeable. Many will recall what these spring and summer evening drives did to our windshields. Depending on the accumulation of heat units, the first flight of European corn borers generally lasts from mid-May through mid-June. Moths emerge from corn residue and seek out areas of dense vegetation found in ditch banks, fence rows, and grass waterways. Females emit a sex pheromone in these “action sites” very late in the evening that attracts males and mating ensues. Females depart action sites after sundown and begin laying egg masses in nearby cornfields — typically two egg masses per night for upwards of 10 days. Action sites near cornfields are ideal for the largest aggregation of moths as described by Dr. Tom Sappington in an Environmental Entomology (2005) journal article.
From June 13 to 26, a Department of Crop Sciences research team led by Ron Estes, Principal Research Specialist in Agriculture, and Nicholas Tinsley, Postdoctoral Research Associate, conducted surveys of action sites in the following 12 counties: Champaign (June 13, 5 action sites), Clinton (June 24, 3 action sites), Douglas (June 13, 5 action sites), Fayette (June 24, 4 action sites), Jefferson (June 24, 3 action sites), Kankakee (June 26, 5 action sites), Kendall (June 26, 5 action sites), Knox (June 17, 5 action sites), McLean (June 17, 5 action sites), Pike (June 18, 3 action sites), Sangamon (June 18, 3 action sites), and Whiteside (June 25, 5 action sites). Within each action site, 100 sweeps were taken. Very few moths (9 total) were collected: Champaign County – 1 moth, Douglas County – 3 moths (one in each of 3 sites), Kankakee County – 1 moth, Kendall County – 1 moth, Knox County – 1 moth, McLean County – 1 moth, and Sangamon County – 1 moth. In all, 51 action sites (100 sweeps/site) were sampled across 12 counties resulting in 5,100 sweeps that yielded 9 moths, or 0.0018 moths per sweep.
Based upon these results, I believe the following questions are worthy of consideration.
- Are too few survivors emerging from Bt fields to sustain the continuing efficacy of Bt hybrids against European corn borers? So far, no field-selected Bt resistant strains of European corn borers have been documented.
- Will the smaller (5%) seed-blend refuges result in even fewer European corn borer survivors in the landscape and further increase the selection pressure for resistance development? Recall that structured 20% refuges were the norm for Bt corn hybrids for many years. In addition, the structured refuge was a preferred resistance management approach along with the use of high-dose Bt hybrids for European corn borers. Early on, concern over larval movement from plant to plant by European corn borer larvae resulted in scientists favoring a structured refuge versus a seed blend for this insect pest.
- Is the added cost of Bt hybrids worth the investment for this insect pest in light of very low densities of the European corn borer and the less than favorable current and projected commodity prices?
- If the use of Bt hybrids declined, would producers have sufficient time to scout large commercial cornfields, utilize economic thresholds, and apply rescue treatments as needed?
Time will tell if this once very significant insect pest will return as a consistent threat.